You could earn SmartPoints on this page!SmartPoint Coin
Coaches ADHD Test Store
Join NOW!
Health Interest Support Group Resources   ▶   BlogsQ & ARecipes

HelloLife

Health Interest Blogs

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! — health article from the Health Interest Support Group on the Smart Living Network
Featured Article
December 16 2011 at 3:54 pmComments: 4 Views: 471 Faves: 0

Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds!

By
From the Id and Ego Blog Series

It’s that special time of the week again! Time for fun with human folly – it’s your psychology tidbit of the week – Id and Ego is back!

This week: new research investigates our ability to spot a lie and just what it is that gives liars away.

Let’s get to it!

Little White Lying.

New research from the University of California, Berkeley shows that we pass judgments pretty quickly on the trustworthiness of a stranger.

In their study, researchers asked 24 couple to have a conversation on film. One person was asked to describe a time when they had suffered, the other was asked to listen.

These videos then were then viewed by another set of study participants who, within in 20 seconds of watching these complete strangers, were able to identify false compassion in the listeners!

Catching a Liar.

What was it these people saw? How can you be sure you’re not being tricked?

As behavioral psychologist, Marc Salem Ph.D. suggets – forget the words.  Body language speaks much louder than our voice in that regard.

In fact, according to Salem there are 5 signs in particular he says to look out for:

  1. Inconsistent Behavior. Animation and speech patterns should remain fairly consistent if a person is comfortable. A drastic change – from very still to very animated or vice versa should set off alarms. A change from smooth, rapid speech to  a calculated, clipped speech pattern is another sign. “Shifts from the norm are red flags for deceit,” said Salem.
  2. A Very Steady Gaze. Perhaps we’ve been told too often to “Look me in the eye!”, but many of us are under the impression that a liar won’t lie with a direct gaze. That’s not exactly the case according to Salem. In FACT, he suggests the opposite – a very steady gaze, he says is a red flag. “When people think or contemplate, it’s natural for them to break eye contact and look around,” Liars on the other hand, probably under the same mistaken impression that many of us are, often try to maintain a steady gaze, as they are consciously trying to appear trustworthy.
  3. Covered Mouth. It’s another one of those funny examples of the mind reacting to the symbolism of our body’s actions - like washing our hands when we’re feeling guilty, like feeling in a “heavy” mood when we’re carrying a load.  Often times, explains Salem, liars subconsciously cover their mouth because they are trying to hide something. Coughing or frequent throat clearing is another give away - it's as though the liar's body is trying to expel the lie and guilt.
  4. Hunched Body. When we lie, it’s a vulnerable time. While telling the truth may create problems, being caught in a lie about the truth adds a WHOLE new dimension! It’s a scary thing, and because of that, liars often take a cautious, protective posture – shoulders down, back hunched – protecting our vital organs and at the same time comforting ourselves with a posture closer to that curled "fetal" position we held in the womb.
  5. Very Quick Smile.  While a genuine smile lasts a couple of seconds and affects the whole face – the eyebrows, eyes, cheeks and corners of the moutha genuine smile is far more contained and fades immediately after appearing.

Lying.

Whether it’s a little white, a tall tale, or a big whopper, there isn’t a single one among us that doesn’t do it. And that’s not always a bad thing!

The truth can cut. Our honest opinion of that new haircut could endanger our friendship. What we really think about our boss’s new tie could endanger our job.

As anyone who’s seen Jim Carry in “Liar, Liar” can tell you, (And if you haven’t, you really should – its hilarious.) lying is an important part of our success in the social world!

HOWEVER, with that said, no matter the motivation - no one likes to find out they’ve been lied to. My advice – tell the truth whenever possible. But if you’re going to do, cross your fingers and hope the lie-receiver hasn’t just read this blog too! ;)

Photo Credit: Katie Tegtmeyer

4 Comments

Respond on facebook (Post to facebook and HelloLife)

  • Mohamed Mohamed

    Nice topic :)
    Commented on HelloLife December 20 2011 at 3:04 pm

  • Nancy Nancy

    Cool - is it really that easy?
    Commented on HelloLife December 20 2011 at 4:01 pm

  • Bri Luginbill Bri Luginbill

    Wow, very interesting. I definitely think the Steady Gaze one is right on. I always break eye contact if I am trying to think while talking to someone.

    I think the "hunched body" one can be confused with self-consciousness though. Sometimes I may slouch if I am self-conscious. This doesn't mean I am lying, it just means I'm a bit nervous in that certain situation.
    Commented on HelloLife December 21 2011 at 7:47 am

  • Erin Froehlich Erin Froehlich

    Thanks everyone! :D

    Bri - You bring up a really good point! None of the body signals discussed are exclusive to lying. This is really more of a crash course on body language, meant to open people to the idea of interpreting the body.

    I'd say use your gut when it comes to interpreting signals of discomfort and unease - which is essentially what all 5 of those points are displaying. It could be anxiety or self-consciousnesses, like you said. It could also be that the conversation simply struck a nerve.

    Consider why you are suspicious. Are YOU feeling guilty? Another common side effect of lying is heightened suspicion and paranoia. (Yet another reason to stick with the truth!) :/

    Consider what motive the person might even have to lie and if there another reason for the suspected liar to be feeling uncomfortable?

    In the end, while it is helpful to understand the way a lie affects our body and they way a lie can look, it really comes down to intuition - which according to the new study - we do seem very capable of! Within 20 seconds people could spot the insincerity of a stranger.

    We are social animals and we existed before our language did - in that time it was essential to our survival that we be able to assess another person's trustworthiness. Today, while there is much more to distract, we still have that in us.

    If a person is striking you as untrustworthy, I'd say listen to what your instincts are telling you.
    Commented on HelloLife December 21 2011 at 8:48 am

Comment on HelloLife

Already a member? Just sign in!

What's YOUR take on this? Does it bring up any questions? Can you offer more information on this? Did you just enjoy reading it? Leave your comment here!


You are at least 13 years of age and agree to our terms of service.

(All fields Reqiuired)

Report Abuse

The Week in Health

This blog is part
of issue #7 of
The Week in Health.

Read this issue!

More from Erin Froehlich
More from this series, "Id and Ego"

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

The Nose Knows! Study Shows We Can SMELL Personality Traits

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

Psychologists Identify the Facebook and Twitter Personality Type

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

PKMzeta - A Memory Wipe Pill Has Been Created!

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

I Don't WANT To Be Jolly! Top 10 Holiday Dreads Revealed

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

Getting To Know You: The 15 Best Questions to Really Get To Know Someone

Most Popular

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

Sammi, the paraplegic dog, walks again!

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

Asperger's and ADHD, What's the Difference?

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

The Whole Truth About Tail Docking

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

GET TO KNOW: Kale

[Id and Ego] Catch A Lie in 20 Seconds! health article

Allie Brosh's battle with depression - and why it should matter to you

Subscribe to THRIVE
The HelloLife Newsletter

Popular Reading Topics


Suggest a Support Group Feedback